1. What are two of Justice Fortas's basic reasons for ruling in favor of the students?

2. What are two of Justice Black's basic reasons for disagreeing with the majority opinion?

3. Why do the judges reference other cases in their explanations?

4. Do you think students should have the same rights in school as outside of school? Why or why not?

Question

English

Amirah Pham

7 May, 15:32

1. What are two of Justice Fortas's basic reasons for ruling in favor of the students?

2. What are two of Justice Black's basic reasons for disagreeing with the majority opinion?

3. Why do the judges reference other cases in their explanations?

4. Do you think students should have the same rights in school as outside of school? Why or why not?

+1

Answers (1)

Know the Answer?

Diamond · Answer 1

The Justice Fortas was an associate justice of Supreme Court of the US. During 1965 students wore armbands to express their discontent with war, the schooling system attempted to suspend them but Justice Fortas ruled in favor of the students because:

The first Ammendment. He believed both students and teachers have the right to freedom of speach in and outside school boundaries. School officials only banned anti-war bands specifically therefore any other type of armband should be allowed.

The answer to number two is that Justice Black believes that there were in fact disruptions as a result of students wearing armbands and also he believes that states should be free to make laws for their schools as they see fit without the Supreme Court overruling them.