Identify the problem with pronoun reference as ambiguous, remote, or broad

When Jill picked up Nancy on the way to the game, she said she had forgotten the tickets

Question

English

Jaxon Whitaker

3 July, 17:26

Identify the problem with pronoun reference as ambiguous, remote, or broad

When Jill picked up Nancy on the way to the game, she said she had forgotten the tickets

+1

Answers (1)

Know the Answer?

Dayton Pennington · Answer 1

The ambiguity here is that we do not know whether she refers to Jill telling Nancy or to Nancy telling Jill. There are no logical laws that determine who said it, we just associate it naturally with the first option because Jill came first in the sentence.

Identify the problem with pronoun reference as ambiguous, remote, or broadWhen Jill picked up Nancy on the way to the game, she said she had forgotten the tickets

Identify the problem with pronoun reference as ambiguous, remote, or broad

When Jill picked up Nancy on the way to the game, she said she had forgotten the tickets