Ask Question
10 December, 06:28

How would you respond to a person who tells you not to believe scientific theory because theories are only possible for explanations that are not packed by evidence

+3
Answers (1)
  1. 10 December, 07:25
    0
    I would explain to him ... calmly, coolly, and patiently ... that

    the 'evidence' is always there before the theory.

    Real scientists do not gaze into their tea leaves, dream up theories

    that sound cool, and then go out to find evidence that supports the

    theory. That is not the way that science works, and any individual

    who operates that way is simply never heard from again.

    In real science, everybody keeps his eyes wide open, observing

    everything that goes on around him, measuring it, photographing it,

    keeping records of how often it happens, in what situations and

    under what conditions, and what came before and after it.

    Eventually, he tries to put together an explanation of what causes

    the things that he has seen, and how they work. The explanation

    must fit what he has seen. That explanation is his theory, created

    to explain what has already been seen.

    And if the explanation is any good, it predicts things that have

    not been seen yet, but he and other scientists can look for them.

    If they look and do find them, then those findings support the

    theory. If they look and find things completely opposite to what

    the theory predicts, then two things could happen: Either the

    theory is adjusted to account for the new observations, or else

    the theory is completely rejected.

    So, your friend has stated that theories are only possible when

    not backed by evidence. When he makes that statement, he

    reveals that he knows not whereof he speaks, for the truth is

    exactly the opposite: Theories arise out of evidence, and where

    there is no evidence, there's no need for a theory, and no theory

    is possible.
Know the Answer?
Not Sure About the Answer?
Get an answer to your question ✅ “How would you respond to a person who tells you not to believe scientific theory because theories are only possible for explanations that ...” in 📙 Physics if there is no answer or all answers are wrong, use a search bar and try to find the answer among similar questions.
Search for Other Answers