Gabrielle, the owner of an apartment building, claimed that Antonio, one of her tenants, did not pay rent for six months. She said Antonio owed her $4,800. The case was heard before a court in Georgia. After both sides presented their cases, the judge rendered a verdict in favor of Antonio because Gabrielle could not produce a contract stating the amount owed. Gabrielle filed an appeal of the decision because she believed the judge ruled incorrectly.

Question

Social Studies

Queen Bee

12 May, 01:53

Gabrielle, the owner of an apartment building, claimed that Antonio, one of her tenants, did not pay rent for six months. She said Antonio owed her $4,800. The case was heard before a court in Georgia. After both sides presented their cases, the judge rendered a verdict in favor of Antonio because Gabrielle could not produce a contract stating the amount owed. Gabrielle filed an appeal of the decision because she believed the judge ruled incorrectly.

+3

Answers (1)

Know the Answer?

Amelia Bauer · Answer 1

Gabrielle might not win the appeal decision.

Signed documents whenever you received something whether it is monetary, item, services or renting properties are important. As well as billing statements as a proof that you have an amount to be paid. Courts recognize these documents as evidence that there is a transaction involved. This is also applicable to renting businesses. Gabrielle should have issued signed billing statement to Antonio as a proof that he has due amount to be settled in his rent. Aside from that, the billing statement should bear Antonio's signature as an evidence that he has received the billing statement and aware of his responsibilities. Together with receipts, these could be presented in court and would really strengthens Gabrielle's argument that Antonio is not paying.